Nicholas Angelo "Nicky Mouth" Santora (June 21, 1942 - October 27, 2018) is a reputed capo of the Bonanno crime family. Santora also briefly served as underboss from 2004-2007.
Nicholas Santora was born on June 21, 1942, and became known in his teens as a tough mobster from New York City. He was the son of Modesto Santora, a sidewalk soldier for the Colombo crime family underboss Joseph Magliocco. Originally a member of a youth gang, Santora became a made man along with mobsters Dominick Napolitano, Benjamin Ruggiero and Joseph Massino in the mid 1970s.
When Santora became involved with the Bonanno family, the boss was the imprisoned Phillip Rastelli. Rastelli's reign was threatened by Carmine Galante, who felt he was the rightful boss because he had been underboss and consigliere under boss Joseph Bonanno. Santora started out in a crew led by Galante-supporter Michael Sabella, and became heavily involved with extortion, loansharking, labor racketeering, illegal gambling, truck hijacking, and murder for hire.
By 1978, Phillip Rastelli had heard rumors of Carmine Galante being the new boss of the Bonannos, but wouldn't tolerate it. Another caporegime, Alphonse Indelicato, would be approached by Rastelli to organize the murder of Carmine Galante. Alphonse Indelicato approached Santora, whose job was to deliver the message to mobsters Dominick Napolitano and Cesare Bonventre and report back to Indelicato. Since Michael Sabella was loyal to Galante, it had to happen without Sabella knowing it.
On July 12, 1979, Carmine Galante was murdered just as he finished eating lunch at Joe and Mary's Italian-American Restaurant at in Bushwick, Brooklyn along with friend Leonard Coppola and restaurant owner/cousin Giuseppe Turano. He was murdered by Anthony Indelicato, Dominick Trinchera, Dominick Napolitano and Louis "Louie Gaeta" Giongetti, who were all hired by Alphonse Indelicato.
After the Galante execution, several Galante supporters, including Michael Sabella, were demoted, as Dominick Trinchera, Dominick Napolitano and Cesare Bonventre were all promoted to captains of the Bonanno crime family. It is suspected his death was arranged by the heads of the other major Five Families in New York, who had decided Galante's greed and ambition over the control of the multimillion-dollar heroin business were a threat to all their interests. Phillip Rastelli was also involved and remained boss of the Bonannos.
With Dominick Napolitano as capo, The Motion Lounge crew would receive massive income as one of the most profitable crews in the Bonanno family. With soldiers Nicholas Santora, John Cersani, John Zancocchio, Edward Barberra, Benjamin Ruggiero, demoted capo Michael Sabella, Joseph Puma, Steven Maruca, Salvatore Farrugia, Antonio Tomasulo, Anthony "Fat Tony" Rabito, Frank DiStefano, Salvatore D'Ottavio, James Episcopa, and infamous Mafia associate Joseph "Donnie Brasco" Pistone, who was an FBI agent working undercover.
Napolitano, after three years of work in Brooklyn, moved operations to Florida in 1980, where he and Donnie Brasco set up loansharking, illegal gambling, extortion, and racketeering operations with the permission of longtime Florida Boss Santo Trafficante. It was around this time that Santora would be put in charge of the entire Florida operation, along with Brasco. Back in New York, the leadership of Phillip Rastelli wasn't so popular anymore, as Alphonse Indelicato was seen as a more prominent figure as boss of the Bonanno family, which is why Dominick Napolitano moved operations into Florida, in hope of squeezing the rival faction out financially. Alphonse Indelicato and two other captains, Dominick Trinchera and Phillip Giaccone began planning on taking over the family.
The three capos murder
Some of the clubs in Florida were eventually shut down due to local police and more pressure on organized crime. Eventually, they got back to New York, where the rival Indelicato faction had grown larger and more powerful. On May 5, 1981, just when a new war was about to break out in the Bonanno family, Alphonse Indelicato, Phillip Giaccone, and Dominick Trinchera were shot to death in an ambush at the old 20/20 Club, a night club owned by Gambino crime family underboss Salvatore Gravano. Indelicato's body turned up three weeks later in the Ruby street lot (Mafia graveyard) in Ozone Park, Queens, but the remains of the other two were not unearthed until 2004.
According to FBI agent Joseph Pistone, the murderers involved in the assassination of Indelicato were Nicholas Santora, Dominick Napolitano, John Cersani, Joseph Massino, Salvatore Vitale, Joseph DeSimone, Vito Rizzuto, Louis Giongetti, Santo Giordano, and Gerlando Sciascia. Benjamin Ruggiero and John Cersani were lookouts, and sent in after to clean up the massacre and dispose of the bodies along with Santora, Dominick Napolitano, James Episcopia, and Robert Capazzio.
Operation Donnie Brasco
Anthony Indelicato went into hiding after the three capo slayings and the Rastelli supporters had basically won the Bonnano civil war. Santora had taken over The Motion Lounge crew, and Dominick Napolitano had been promoted to "street boss" for Phillip Rastelli, who was still incarcerated. Brasco's FBI operation ended when Napolitano organized the scrapped murder of Anthony Indelicato and gave it to Donnie Brasco, to make him a made man in the Bonanno family.
It was revealed days later that Donnie Brasco was really Joseph D. Pistone, an undercover agent for the FBI. Pistone spent six years undercover. The order came down shortly after to kill Dominick Napolitano for having allowed such a breach in Mafia security. On August 17, 1981, Napolitano was asked to come to the basement of Bonanno associate Ron Filocomo in Flatlands, Brooklyn, where he was ambushed by Filocomo and capo Frank Lino, both of whom shot him to death. The contract came from Santora and Joseph Massino, on behalf of Rastelli.
Santora became capo of Napolitano's old crew, but was soon put under indictment followed by the testimony provided by Pistone. With Phillip Rastelli out of prison when they finally needed him, a total of 100 Bonanno crime family mobsters would be put on trial and convicted, including Phillip Rastelli and Anthony Indelicato, who were both found guilty of racketeering and the murder Carmine Galante along with nine other Mafia associates in the infamous Mafia Commission Trial in 1986.
Santora, along with Benjamin Ruggiero, Antonio Tomasulo, and Anthony "Fat Tony" Rabito, would be convicted in a six-week jury trial for illegal gambling racketeering, distribution of narcotics and conspiracy to distribute narcotics, in the mid 1980s, receiving an 8-10-year prison sentence. After the Mafia Commission Trial in 1986, Bonanno Boss, Phillip Rastelli, would be sentenced to 12 years in prison, released due to heart troubles on July 21, 1991, but died three days later in a Queens hospital on July 24. Joseph Massino took over as boss of the Bonanno family in August 1991.
Upon Santora's release in 1992, he created a partnership with newly promoted Bonanno acting consigliere, Anthony Rabito, in extortion, loansharking, illegal gambling, drug trafficking and money laundering operations in Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx, throughout the mid 1990s. Nicholas Santora, Anthony Rabito and Massino's brother-in-law, Salvatore Vitale, became close with Massino and they expanded their operations to become the top earners in the Bonanno crime family toward the late 1990s. Joseph Massino and the Bonanno family were brought back into the Five Families Commission again, after being expelled because of the Donnie Brasco fiasco.
In 2000, longtime Bonanno family consigliere, Anthony Spero, was indicted on loansharking, racketeering and murder in November and in 2001 he was sentenced to life imprisonment. That gave Anthony Rabito a promotion as the official consigliere of the Bonannos. Toward 2003, indictments were again handed out, this time against their own boss and underboss, as Joseph Massino and Salvatore Vitale were held against bail for racketeering, arson, extortion, loansharking, money laundering, illegal gambling, conspiracy and seven murders. Because of this, Nicholas Santora was promoted to acting underboss in 2003.
The indictments were also against capos Anthony Urso and James "Big Lou" Tartaglione, who secretly agreed to a wear wire, and turn government witnesses. As Santora kept flying under the radar with Anthony Rabito, underboss Salvatore Vitale turned informant as the two capos handed him out in murder and racketeering charges, and with Joseph Massino on trial in March, 2004, the government put capos Michael "Mikey Nose" Mancuso and Vincent Basciano on trial for racketeering charges, which included murder and conspiracy.
Massino turns informant
In October 2004, the FBI began to dig up bodies at an infamous mob graveyard in Queens, known as "The Hole". They were looking for the bodies of three capos killed in the Bonanno family war in 1981. They found the bodies of Gambino crime family boss John Gotti's neighbour John Favara, Gotti's Associate Ronald Jerothe and the three Bonanno family capos, Alphonse Indelicato, Phillip Giaccone and Dominick Trinchera. On February 4, 2005, the name of an informant was released to the press; Joseph Massino, who hoped to save his life and his assets, as he began to cooperate sometime in late September 2004, recording conversations with acting boss, Vincent Basciano, who was also convicted and jailed in July 2007.
Despite the testimony of Joseph Massino in 2005, Santora managed to go under the government's radar. At least until he was indicted along with Anthony Rabito, and 17 other members of the Bonanno family, in a loansharking and illegal gambling operation that was stretching from Brooklyn to Queens, Manhattan and Staten Island, which earned $210,000 a week from January 2003 to July 2004. This was mostly because of the death of Bonanno family capo Louis Mele, who died of natural causes in a room where an illegal gambling operation was based.
As of February 13, 2007, Santora was the reputed underboss of the Bonanno family. At the time Vincent Basciano remained the reputed boss of the Bonannos, with Anthony Rabito as the reputed Bonanno consigliere and Salvatore "Sal the Iron Worker" Montagna as acting boss, reporting to Basciano in prison.
Nicholas Santora was released from the Loretto Federal Correctional Institute in southwest Pennsylvania on September 16, 2009.
In January 2012, Santora and several other members of the Bonanno Crime Family, including Bonanno Acting Boss Vincent Badalamenti and soldiers Anthony Calabrese, and Vito Balsamo, and reputed Gambino associate James LaForte were arrested on racketeering and extortion charges. The arrests come in part from information provided by former Bonanno associate and DEA informant Hector Pagan. Santora was charged with conspiracy to distribute marijuana and illegal gambling.
In July 2012, Santora plead guilty to racketeering and extortion charges. In December of 2012, Santora was sentenced to 2 more years in the Federal Correctional Institution in Loretto, PA.
In August 2013, eight members of Santora’s crew were busted for a variety of mob staple rackets including loansharking and drug dealing ( illegally selling prescription erectile dysfunction drugs like Viagra and Cialis), as well as perjury and possession of firearms. Among those arrested were Bonanno acting capos Ernest Aiello and Vito Badamo and Bonanno soldier Anthony Santoro (aka Skinny). Due to Santora’s involvement with his crew’s rackets and for associating with mob associates while in prison over the phone, Santora had his bail revoked and could face up to 25 years in prison.
On July 16, 2014 Santora turned down a plea deal for 7-to-21 years in prison arguing that he is not involved in enterprise corruption.
On May 10, 2016, after almost three years in prison and a nearly three-month trial and eight days of deliberations, the case against Santora and his co-defendants ended in a mistrial. The mistrial was brought about due to conflict among the jurors. Bail for the four mobsters was set and the case was adjourned to June 23 to discuss the next trial.
Since Santora's mistrial in 2016, he'd been living with his daughter in Franklin Square, New York. Nicholas Santora died on October 27, 2018 at the age of 76, while awaiting his new trial.
Santora is portrayed as "Nicky", by Bruno Kirby in the 1997 film Donnie Brasco, which follows the life of undercover agent Joseph D. Pistone, from 1978 to 1981. The character "Nicky" was shot and killed in the movie, whereas Santora was not.